​Jonah PB Goldwater
PUBLICATIONS
​
"Uploads, Faxes, and You: Why Personal Identity is Non-Transferable"
​
(Forthcoming). American Philosophical Quarterly.
​
You can be faxed only if you're an abstract object, so you can be uploaded only if you're an abstract object. So Chalmers' argument for 'gradual uploading' fails.
​
​
"Freedom and Actual Interference"
​
(Forthcoming). The Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy.
​
Liberal or noninterference conceptions of freedom do indeed have the resources to explain what proponents of republican or non-dominination conceptions of freedom claim they cannot.
​
​
"Six Arguments Against 'Ought Implies Can'"
​
(Forthcoming). Southwest Philosophy Review 36 (1), 2020.
​
I present six arguments against 'OIC' that only invoke general principles; no cases.
​
​
​
(Forthcoming). Philosophia.
​
How many things exist can be genuinely, metaphysically, indeterminate- contra the orthodox view. Upshot: the 'are there n or n+1 things?' approach to metaphysics is likely misguided.
​
​
“The Lump and the Ledger: Material Coincidence At Little-to-No-Cost”
​
(Forthcoming). Erkenntnis.
​
I defend a number of methodological theses regarding cost-benefit tradeoffs in metaphysical theory choice. I also explain why it’s fine if the statue and the clay coincide.
​
"The Physical as the Nomalous"
​
(2019). The Journal of Consciousness Studies, 26 (5–6): 65–88.
​
I defend a new conception of physicalism as true iff all events are law-governed. Free will—not consciousness—is likely the crux.
​
"Ryle, the Double Counting Problem, and the Logical Form of Category Mistakes"
(2018). Journal of the History of Philosophy, 56 (2): 337–359.
​
Category mistakes are not only mistakes of predication. They are also mistakes of conjunction and quantification. Big restrictions on ontology follow.
​
​
"Physicalism and the Sortalist Conception of Objects"
(2018). Synthese, 195 (12): 5497–5519.​
​
Physicalism is incompatible with the (neo)Aristotelian metaphysics of objects- in particular its kind-based essentialism. The physicalist picture is likely Heraclitean instead.
​
​
"Authority and Natural Kind Essence"
​
(2018). Axiomathes, 28 (1): 1–12.
​
Water may be H2O, but the essence of water being H2O is conventional or trivial- and likely dictated by authority.
​
​
"Existence and Strong Uncountability"
​
(2017). Acta Analytica, 32 (3): 321–331.
​
Existence is standardly understood in terms of number: for something to exist is for one thing to exist. I argue this is a mistake. A revisionary reading of quantification follows.
​
"No Composition, No Problem: Ordinary Objects as Arrangements"
(2015). Philosophia, 43 (2): 367-379.
Tables and chairs exist- even if atoms arranged table- and chair-wise don't compose wholes. For tables and chairs are whatever you're sitting on- even if that's just an arrangements of atoms!
​
​
(2014). Metaphysica: International Journal for Ontology and Metaphysics, 15 (1): 99–112.
​
Taking quantifiers and connectives to carve at nature's joints undercuts the ontology/ideology distinction, and requires an exotic form of logical realism. Despite Sider's claims to the contrary​​​​.
​
PAPERS UNDER REVIEW
"Fatalism and the Artifice of Logic"*
​
Like physical laws, many logical laws are idealized. But then arguing for fatalism via a logical law can be like arguing friction doesn't exist via a law that idealizes away friction.
​
​
"How Nature Threatens Freedom Too"*
The standard view in political philosophy is that only persons can take away a person's freedom. I argue nature can too.
​
​
"Paraphrase, Categories, Ontology"*
​
Paraphrasing away ontological commitment is a misguided enterprise, as commitment is nothing to fear!
​
​
* Names changed for anonymous review
SOME WORKS IN PROGRESS
"Autonomy and Freedom"
​
Not so different after all.
​
​
"Liberty and regulations"
​
Laws and regulations protect freedom, rather than interfere with it. (Even Mill's classical liberalism justifies this.)
​
​
“Ordinary-Object Eliminativism is Empirically False”
​
One can tell a table exists just by looking.
​
​
“Metaphysical Theory Choice and Cost-Benefit Analyses"
​
CBAs don't work like metaphysicians think they do (a cost), and aren't good for selecting theories (also a cost).
​
​
"Metaontology and Category Mistakes"
​
The debate over the existence of composite objects rests on a category mistake.
​
​
"A Dilemma for Property-Quidditism"
​
Structuralism about properties avoids a dilemma faced by property-quidditism
​
​
“A Puzzle for Ontological Novelty"
​
It is surprisingly difficult to formulate the distinction between substantial and accidental change.
​
​